Milwaukee-made, market-fresh, dangerously delicious.
What are Grandmas Gonna Do Now?™
Milwaukee’s pie shop at 3rd Street Market Hall. Slices, halves, and whole pies—plus Savory pasties & seasonal specials.
10.6K
Followers On Instagram
18K
Followers On Facebook
16.7K
Followers On Twitter
What We Do...
Sweet
From classic comforts to bold new flavors, our sweet pies are baked to bring joy in every slice.
Savory
Hearty, golden, and filled with flavor, our savory pies turn every meal into a comforting occasion.
Breads
Freshly baked loaves with rich flavor and texture, perfect for sharing—or keeping all to yourself.
Irish Sea Moss Gel
Packed with minerals and natural goodness, our Irish Sea Moss Gel is a simple way to boost your day. Add it to smoothies, teas, or enjoy by the spoonful for a clean, nourishing lift.
Drinks
Simple, refreshing choices to pair perfectly with your favorite slice, from classic sodas to crisp water.
Elderberry Syrup
Rich in antioxidants and tradition, our Elderberry Syrup helps keep you strong through every season. Sweet, tart, and soothing—it’s wellness made delicious.
Our Story
Mr. Dye’s Pies started with a single mission: to bake pies that taste like home. Founded by Johnathan Dye, our bakery has blossomed into a beloved Milwaukee staple, nestled inside 3rd Street Market Hall. Every pie—sweet or savory—is crafted with passion, tradition, and a sprinkle of local pride.
Today, we take pride in offering both our celebrated sweet pies and a bold new twist: savory pasties, perfect for when you crave something hearty as much as something sweet.
“At Mr. Dye’s Pies, we don’t just bake—we share joy, family, and flavor with every slice.”
Jarron Herndon
Manager
Sign Up Now!
- Exclusive offers and seasonal pie announcements
- Early access to holiday pre-orders
- Market Hall updates so you never miss your favorite flavors